Skip to content
PTEN

False Thoughts: Should You Respect Them, Yes or No?

By Jorge Amaro · 11 September 2019 · 13 min read

Retrato de uma mulher pensativa a olhar para o lado, à luz natural
In this article
  1. In short
  2. False thoughts and psychological suffering: what is the connection?
  3. Asking for help is an act of strength, not weakness
  4. False thoughts: book a session or not?
  5. You arrive at the practice carrying many false thoughts

In short

  • We all have automatic thoughts that are not very true, like fake news that the mind keeps repeating.
  • When they take hold, they can bring suffering, rituals to relieve it and, in some cases, obsessions and compulsions.
  • Asking for help is an act of strength, not weakness: only someone who recognises that they need help can be helped.
  • See also negative thoughts and how to challenge them.

The full reflection by Jorge Amaro follows.

False thoughts and psychological suffering: what is the connection?

False thoughts are a plague, just like fake news! You know that a lot of not-very-true thoughts pass through your head, don't you? Yes, CBT says so: they pass through all the time, and they harm you! And you often say that sentence, "I'm suffering psychologically and I don't even know why…"

You may want to see a psychologist, or you may be looking for therapists because you are suffering. And you naturally want to get past your psychological suffering. You want to overcome trauma, get past difficulties, treat something that torments your life, that brings you sadness, anxiety, anguish, fear.

Asking for help is an act of strength, not weakness

If this is your case, first of all, let us tell you that, all things considered, you deserve congratulations. Some people are suffering but do not recognise that they need help. You, on the other hand, admit that you really do want help. You are willing to turn to the psychological support of someone with the technical and scientific training to provide it!

Yes, that is the first step, and it undoubtedly has to be taken: you can take it now.

False thoughts: book a session or not?

Not everyone gets this far. And this is where the situation can get worse. You may be in this position: "Shall I book a session with a psychologist or not?…" So you may be hesitating about whether to phone, to send a message…

Or perhaps you know someone in that situation. It might be, for example, a young person, the son of a work colleague, who has stopped going out, who doesn't leave the house, who feels no enthusiasm for anything, who spends his life lying down… And that young person has been told that the best thing would be to see a psychologist. But he says no, that he's fine, that he doesn't need anyone's help. And he may even say that he isn't crazy, and for that very reason doesn't need to see a psychologist.

Unfortunately, there are many cases like this that go without any help.

You arrive at the practice carrying many false thoughts

But, fortunately, more and more people turn to a psychologist or a psychotherapist. There is still progress to be made on this path, but more and more people are seeking specialist psychological help.

When a person arrives at the practice, they come suffering. The degree of suffering varies, of course, but there is a request, even if it is often not entirely explicit in the first session: "I have a lot of psychological suffering, I can't bear the point I've reached in my life any more…" Often the person is not sure whether they are in depression, but they may be…

Others may say: "I have psychological suffering, I suffer, but I don't even know quite what from, where this pain of mine comes from, this state of torment…" These are sentences that we psychologists, EMDR therapists or CBT therapists, may hear from you if you decide to seek psychological help. Or that we may hear from someone to whom you have recommended our services…

We are all assailed by automatic false thoughts

The origin of people's psychological suffering may lie in things that seem, at first sight, "small". See, for example, whether in your case your psychological suffering lies in the way you interpret the reactions of other people who deal with you.

It may lie in the way you assess certain situations that happen to you in your day-to-day life. It may originate in automatic negative thoughts. All of us are assailed by this kind of automatic thought.

In some cases, that's a good thing. For example, when we cross at a pedestrian crossing, we immediately look both ways, don't we? That is, we had an automatic thought: "Careful, look properly, or a car might hit you!"

Your false thoughts are like fake news

There are, indeed, different kinds of cognitions, beliefs, thoughts, many of them with no great consequences for the normal course of our lives. However, coming back to you, sometimes it would be better if you did not have certain thoughts, wouldn't it? There are those that the psychopathology manuals call intrusive, ruminative thoughts. You have perhaps heard of them, haven't you?

And they don't have to be highly paranoid or highly catastrophic thoughts, no; they can be about matters of minor importance. For example, when you think that a person was unfriendly to you, or simply didn't return your greeting. You immediately take it personally, but later you even realise that it was just someone introverted, shyer and less confident. Or you even find out that they were simply distracted.

Or, after all, that person who behaved badly towards you was just having a bad day, when several unpleasant things had happened to them.

You immediately think you are worthless

You may have thoughts linked to feelings of worthlessness. You may think you are no good, that you are not worth enough, that nobody is interested in you. But these are false thoughts! You may, for example, attach a special meaning to a particular person's reaction.

And you immediately think you have no value, that you don't deserve anything good, that you don't deserve to be loved…

You may, for example, think that if someone didn't reply to a particular e-mail of yours, it is because they saw no interest in it and are therefore devaluing you… And there you are saying, "I have psychological suffering, I suffer a great deal…" Yet most of the time none of that is true: the other person did not reply to your e-mail for some other reason.

There can be so many reasons: perhaps they haven't had time yet, or they receive a lot of e-mails and in the confusion yours got forgotten, and so on and so forth.

You may be suffering psychologically from an invasion of false thoughts

You may be in a depressive state, and the cause of your depression may well lie in the occurrence of many thoughts of this kind: "I'm worthless, because nobody calls me…", "There's no point getting up, because there's nothing good out there…", "Life isn't worth living like this…" So you may be suffering an invasion of this kind of automatic, negative, but certainly false, thoughts.

These days there is a lot of talk about fake news, about the need to learn to tell a fake news story from a true one and vice versa. Well, we also have to learn to tell false thoughts from true ones.

False thoughts misinterpret certain situations, or even the whole of reality. Often those situations are neutral, and sometimes they are even positive, but you immediately invent negative sides and may say, "I have psychological suffering, I suffer a great deal, because nobody cares about me, I have no value…"

If you don't correct these "inventions", you may fall ill or, at the very least, go around unhappy… Is that your case? Is it the case of someone you know? Yes… Unfortunately there are many people like this who really need psychological help!

Your false thoughts: "There's no point…"

So we need to correct mistaken, dysfunctional beliefs. We need to correct thoughts that distort reality. You may think, for example, that someone doesn't like you. And that person may even show warmth towards you and truly like you. But you say no, you interpret it differently.

There may also be, for example, a father who, because he did not do a certain thing for his child, immediately thinks he is a bad father. Or people who never get started on a task because they think there's no point, that they will only get tired, that the work won't all get done, or that it will be imperfect…

Sometimes they may even be thoughts that contain some truth, but not enough to draw such radical final conclusions. And yet, here comes the sentence: "I suffer, my life is permanent psychological suffering, there's no point, I can't do anything, I deserve this…"

You may not be making proper use of the middle ground. But note that there is always a moderate side. Many people are not aware that a middle ground exists; they don't realise that there is always a gradation in the way we think and respond, rather than react.

You can find moderation in your thoughts, so that you can lead a calmer life, in which you get at least reasonable satisfaction from your life. But it is not always easy…

You may perform certain rituals to relieve psychological suffering

We may need someone who, impartially, empathically and with complete availability, helps us formulate thoughts that are more accurate, more suitable, more in tune with reality. We have already said that you may have repetitive, intense, constant, ruminative thoughts… Or that you may know someone who shows signs of great psychological suffering, who suffers mentally.

It may even be someone in your family, with more serious behaviours linked, for example, to obsessions and compulsions…

In this field, a person may feel the need to perform certain rituals. Perhaps that is your case, when you go through those moments in which your thoughts race at high speed, preventing you from being calm… And you want to get rid of them because you find them unpleasant, because they cause you intense unease and discomfort.

We may be talking about those obsessions that eventually go away. Great, it is good when that happens. But the worst is when you have no success and the obsessive thoughts persist, they stay there ruminating, ruminating, and won't go away at all.

And, on top of all this, you may feel an imperative need, almost an obligation, to perform certain rituals, repetitively.

The harder you try to get rid of your obsessions, the worse it gets, doesn't it?

Many people cannot push their obsessions away. It may be your case, or that of someone close to you. Some people suffer a great deal with this kind of problem, with thoughts that bother them enormously.

These are the thoughts that can arise repeatedly, that cause you a lot of anxiety, that seem absurd to you, but that you cannot get rid of. It even seems that the harder you try to get rid of your obsessions, the worse it gets, doesn't it? You really can't push them out of your head. And then you even discover that if you do a certain thing several times, your anxiety, your psychological suffering, eases, lessens somewhat…

"You have Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder!"

In principle, we all know people whose behaviour takes an exaggerated form. The examples of people obsessed with personal cleanliness, or with the cleanliness of the house, the car, the objects around them are well known. So are the cases where the person goes back several times to check that they have properly shut a door. You may be one of these people. Or you may know someone for whom a certain routine, such as dressing or showering, takes hours. Or you may know someone who is extremely demanding about the arrangement of the knick-knacks at home, about the symmetry of the pictures on a wall.

Of course, in "small doses" these kinds of behaviour are not worrying; they may even belong to people with high aesthetic standards. The problem comes when they become exaggerated. And along comes the label OCD: "You have Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder!" All of this is well described in a great big tome, the DSM-5, the great manual of mental disorders. And here we enter the world of Psychiatry and psychiatric medication, quite different from the world of "Psychologies & Psychotherapies"…

Psychological suffering is out there, built on false thoughts!

Psychological suffering, then, really does exist! It is out there! Often with big psychiatric labels. These are disorders that really do spoil the quality of life of many people. Because the person feels they have to do something to push away the great discomfort caused by anxiety and the anguish associated with it. They feel they are obliged to do something to reduce this discomfort, this terrible psychological suffering. That may be the explanation for the so-called compulsive rituals, within the picture of compulsions.

It may also be the explanation for cases of self-harm, of deliberately inflicted cuts and wounds on the body. They are, as it were, protective behaviours, which seem to protect, which seem to reduce a deeper psychological suffering. But only in appearance. They are, in truth, inappropriate.

Many of these compulsions, unlike obsessions, which are hidden further inside the mind, may be visible to other people's eyes. And then they often become the target of mockery and jeers. But most of the time, the person hides their strange behaviour from others. They live the situation alone, suffering without knowing that they can count on the help of someone specialised in the matter.

Always afraid of being found out, always trying to hide the psychological suffering

You may be suffering this kind of problem in solitude. You may have this kind of symptom, similar ones, or even others that seem different. You may be one of those people who won't touch a door handle because of germs. You may even realise that you are behaving in a way that makes no sense. But you can't stop doing it, can you? And so you don't say anything to anyone. You suffer in solitude, always afraid of being found out, always trying to hide it.

This can naturally lead a person to great emotional, and often physical, exhaustion. Perhaps you know that there are obsessions and compulsions that eat up hours of a person's day. They consume precious time and interfere with work and personal life, oscillating between periods when the disorder is more intense and periods of greater calm. And it can all come together in an explosive mixture, for example depression and social phobia, and the problem becomes even worse…

Only someone who recognises they need help can be helped

Do you think you may be in this kind of situation, or close to it? Do you want to control your obsessions and compulsions? Your anxieties, your anguish, your fears or even panic attacks? Are you in permanent, or very frequent, psychological suffering? Do you know someone in this situation? Someone who might admit, "Yes, I have psychological suffering, I suffer a great deal, I realise I need help and I want to be helped…" But it may be someone who has not yet become aware that they really need help. In that case, there is nothing to be done yet. However, the person may change and realise, at some point in their life, that they cannot go on like this and that the time has come to act for a healthy change, in pursuit of the happiness they long for…

Only those who want to be helped can be helped

We at Psicovias are available to give you the help you need. For you, for people you know, or for people close to you. Book a session, in the most varied ways and in different formats, in person or at a distance… See here how to do it…

Jorge Amaro

Jorge AmaroPsychologist and psychotherapist, founder and coordinator of Psicovias · OPP licence no. 3076About Jorge Amaro →

Would you like to talk to a psychologist? Book your session on WhatsApp, in Lisbon or online.

Message us on WhatsApp

Keep reading