Skip to content
PTEN

Can depression be cured? Understanding rationalisation and what it hides

By Jorge Amaro · 17 December 2022 · 6 min read

Retrato de uma mulher pensativa a olhar para o lado, à luz natural
In this article
  1. Can depression be cured?
  2. What rationalisation is
  3. Rationalising in a healthy way or in excess
  4. Everyday examples
  5. Does this sound like you?
  6. When rationalisation increases
  7. What you can do right now
  8. When to ask for help
  9. Treatment for depression in Lisbon and online
  10. Frequently asked questions about depression and rationalisation
  11. Sources and further reading

Depression can be treated, and recovery is possible. See what rationalisation is, how explaining everything with logic can distance you from what you feel and how therapy helps.

Can depression be cured?

Depression can be treated and recovery is possible. The path and the pace vary from person to person, and nobody can promise you a timescale.

For many people, part of that path involves understanding the defence mechanisms we use without realising it. One of them is rationalisation, which we look at next. To recognise the signs of the illness, see the symptoms of depression.

Quick summary

  • Depression can be treated and recovery is possible
  • Rationalising means explaining with logic what is hard to feel
  • In excess, it distances us from the real reasons
  • Therapy is a good space to face them

What rationalisation is

Rationalising is giving logical explanations for what happened to us or for what we feel. It is healthy: it is how we try to understand our difficulties.

The problem is excess. When we use arguments that seem logical but are fallacious, to protect our "self" and avoid feeling what hurts, rationalisation becomes a defence mechanism. We genuinely believe these explanations, because they help us feel better.

In a few words

  • It is a common defence mechanism
  • It uses arguments that seem logical
  • It protects us from difficult emotions
  • In excess, it distances us from what we really feel

Rationalising in a healthy way or in excess

The difference lies in what we do with the emotions.

Healthy rationalisation

  • It helps you understand what happened
  • It leaves room to feel
  • It recognises limits and weaknesses

Rationalisation in excess

  • It explains everything, but the pain remains
  • It blames other people or circumstances
  • It disguises inner conflicts that are hard to accept

Everyday examples

Almost all of us have done it. It is just worth noticing when it becomes the rule.

  • Failing an exam: Saying you were nervous, instead of admitting that perhaps you did not study enough.
  • Losing a job interview: Concluding that the duties were boring, to soften the frustration.
  • The fox and the grapes: He cannot reach the grapes and says they are sour. It is the classic fable of rationalisation.
  • Problems at work: Putting forward seemingly logical arguments to justify what you did, blaming others.

Does this sound like you?

Without judging yourself, see whether any of these sentences sounds familiar.

  • I explain everything with logic, but inside I still feel bad
  • I always find a reason that does not involve me
  • I avoid talking about what I feel and prefer to argue
  • The more frustrated I am, the more I justify
  • I feel that I am deceiving myself

If you recognise yourself in several of them, that is not a flaw: it is a way of protecting yourself. A professional can help you look at what lies underneath.

When rationalisation increases

It tends to grow when there is a lot to feel and little room to do so.

  • When there is frustration: The more frustrated we are, the more we tend to justify.
  • When the emotion is unbearable: A logical explanation acts as a shield against a pain that seems uncontrollable.
  • When there are inner conflicts: We hide what we do not accept in ourselves, and that stops us from knowing ourselves.
  • When there is insecurity: The explanation softens the discomfort, but only postpones the conflict.

What you can do right now

Small steps to make more room for what you feel.

Notice the explanation

When you hear yourself justifying too much, pause for a moment.

Name the emotion

Before explaining, ask yourself what you are feeling: sadness, fear, anger?

Allow another reason

Ask yourself: what if the reason is something else? Accepting your limitations is part of getting to know yourself.

Talk to someone you trust

Telling someone what you feel, without arguing, is good practice.

When to ask for help

If sadness and tiredness have persisted for more than two weeks, or you feel you can no longer manage everyday life as before, see a mental health professional.

  • The sadness does not go away, even after you "explain" it
  • You avoid feeling and it weighs on your daily life
  • You no longer enjoy what you used to like
  • The symptoms affect your sleep, work or relationships

See also: What depression is, Symptoms of depression.

If you have thoughts of hurting yourself or ending your life, talk to someone you trust today and call 112 (European emergency number). If you feel you are at immediate risk, do not stay alone.

Treatment for depression in Lisbon and online

The best space to face emotions in a healthier way is therapy. See the approaches we offer; we help you choose in the first session.

Frequently asked questions about depression and rationalisation

Can depression be cured?

It can be treated and recovery is possible, each person at their own pace. Part of the path may involve recognising defence mechanisms such as rationalisation.

What is rationalisation in psychology?

It is a defence mechanism in which we give logical but fallacious explanations for what we feel or did, to protect our "self" and soften difficult emotions.

Is rationalising always bad?

No. It is healthy to try to understand difficulties. It becomes a problem when it replaces the real reasons and stops us from feeling.

What does it mean to rationalise emotions?

It is explaining an emotion with logical arguments instead of feeling and accepting it. It can bring immediate relief, but it does not resolve what caused it.

Give me an example of rationalisation.

Failing an exam and saying you were nervous, instead of recognising that you did not study enough. Or saying, as in the fable, that the grapes are sour.

Is rationalisation conscious?

Generally not. We genuinely believe the explanations, because they help us feel better.

How do I know if I rationalise too much?

If you explain everything with logic but the pain continues, or you always find reasons that do not involve you, it is worth talking about it with a professional.

Is rationalisation linked to depression?

There can be a link: avoiding emotional pain does not make it disappear. See what depression is and the symptoms of depression.

How does therapy help?

It gives you a safe space to recognise these mechanisms and face your emotions in a healthier way, without having to justify yourself.

How many sessions are needed?

It depends on each case. We agree a regular rhythm, for example weekly.

Can I have therapy online?

Yes. See how it works in online psychology sessions.

Can EMDR help?

It can, when difficult memories lie behind what you feel. See EMDR treatment for depression.

Is there ADSE reimbursement?

ADSE (the Portuguese public-sector health scheme) reimburses 75% of the amount paid, up to €16 per session, without a medical prescription and up to 24 sessions a year. See psychology sessions with ADSE.

Sources and further reading

Health bodies and reference studies, if you want to read more. They are not a substitute for an assessment by a professional.

Jorge Amaro

Jorge AmaroPsychologist and psychotherapist, founder and coordinator of Psicovias · OPP licence no. 3076About Jorge Amaro →

Would you like to talk to a psychologist? Book your session on WhatsApp, in Lisbon or online.

Message us on WhatsApp

Keep reading